Distinguishing Lion's Mane Extract vs Powder | Botanic Tonics

Distinguishing Lion's Mane Extract vs Powder | Botanic Tonics

Reviewed by Jamal Bouie

Analyzing Lion's Mane Extract vs. Powder: A Distinct Comparison

Lion’s mane mushroom has been taking the wellness world by storm with its vitamin-rich makeup and disease-fighting capabilities. But whether you’re looking to incorporate functional mushrooms like lion’s mane into your wellness regime to boost your brain health, support your digestive system, or strengthen your immunity, you may wonder, what’s the best way to take lion’s mane?

In this article, we’ll outline lion’s mane extract vs. powder to determine which option may be right for you. We’ll explore the potency, health benefits, and ease of use for each so that you can make the most out of this functional fungi. 

What is Lion’s Mane?

Lion’s mane is a shaggy, white, adaptogenic mushroom that’s been used in traditional Chinese medicine for centuries but has only recently gained popularity within the United States. Nicknamed the “Mountain Priest,” lion’s mane, or Hericium erinaceus, is known for its ability to provide both physical and cognitive support.[1]

Lion’s mane contains bioactive compounds in both its mycelium and fruiting body, each with distinct benefits. The mycelium, or the mushroom's root system, provides potent compounds that support overall well-being. The fruiting body – or the visible part of the mushroom – is rich in medicinal compounds, offering a valuable addition to your health routine.

However, it can be tough to ingest enough of this medicinal mushroom to really yield significant benefits. For this reason, people often turn to supplement capsules, tinctures, and even mushroom coffee blends that feature lion’s mane extract or powder. 

Health Benefits: Cognitive Enhancement and Immune Support

So, lion’s mane has recently gained a lot of popularity, but what are functional mushrooms such as this capable of? Whether you’re looking for something to give your body the support it needs for optimal function or you have a specific health concern, lion’s mane may be the magic ingredient you’re missing. 

Here’s a closer look at some of the health benefits of lion’s mane mushroom supplements:[2]

Contains Disease-Fighting Properties

Recent studies have found evidence that suggests that the genetic makeup of lion’s mane contains an array of disease-fighting properties, including antimicrobial, antioxidant, and anti-cancer activity. It may also be able to support:

  • Heart health 
  • Liver function
  • Kidney health

Supports Mood Regulation and Mental Health 

Aside from supporting several of the body’s organs like the heart and liver, lion’s mane may also be an alternative treatment for mood regulation and neuropsychiatric disorders like depression.[3]

Scientists have found that the mushroom has the ability to pass through the blood-brain barrier and stimulate nerves in the hippocampus, creating a natural alternative to conventional antidepressants. 

Scientists have also found that bioactive compounds in lion’s mane can stimulate nerve growth factor (NGF) production.[4] This is an important finding since the neurotrophic and neurogenic pathophysiology of depression indicate that promoting nerve growth may be an effective treatment for the condition. 

Offers Protection Against Dementia and Alzheimer’s Disease

Studies have found that adding Hericium to your diet may be able to improve brain function and boost brain health. While more research is needed for conclusive evidence, scientists are suggesting that lion’s mane mushrooms contain medicinal compounds that may prevent and treat cognitive decline, including conditions like Alzheimer’s Disease and Dementia.[5]

Because it can support your cognitive function, you may also want to take lion’s mane supplements for stress support and overall mood, helping to regulate how you feel, especially if you struggle with nervousness or anxiety.[6]

Provides Your Body with Immune Support

By amping up the activity of the intestinal immune system, lion’s mane may actually be able to offer immune support, helping your body to stave off viruses and bacterial infections. 

These benefits are partially a result of the way lion’s mane changes your body’s gut bacteria, stimulating an immune response.[7]

Understanding Potency: Extract vs. Powder

When deciding between lion’s mane powder vs. extract, you’ll want to consider the potency of each approach. For example, an extract is typically more potent than a powder, which is why you’ll find it in capsules and other easy-to-take options. 

On the other hand, powders are usually less potent. If you go this route, you may have to add a higher volume of lion’s mane to a juice, smoothie, or coffee blend for the same benefits you’d find in a supplement capsule. 

Let’s take a closer look at the potency of lion’s mane in both powder and extract form.

The Power of Lion’s Mane Mushroom Extract

You’ll find highly concentrated lion’s mane extract in tonics, tinctures, and capsules. Because of its potency, it’s easy to integrate enough extract into these smaller items that are easy to drink or swallow, allowing you to get all the benefits of this powerful natural remedy in no time at all. 

This means that when you want to add an extra ~oomph~ to your mental clarity and nervous system performance, it’s easy to make taking a kava mushroom tonic or capsule part of your wellness regime. Since the extraction process is pretty straightforward, you can rest assured that the end result contains all the beneficial compounds found in the mushroom’s raw form.

You’ll probably want to add anywhere from 250mg to 1000mg to your diet, depending on your reason for use and any vitamins or supplements you already take. When opting for products made with lion’s mane extract, it’s easy to know exactly how much Hericium you’re adding to your diet, allowing you to be in total control.

Adding Lion’s Mane Mushroom Powder to Your Diet

If you’re already used to adding protein powder or other additives to your morning smoothie, you might want to consider adding lion’s mane to the list. Whether you’re looking for a cognitive boost or a coffee replacement, you can substitute lion’s mane powder for other ingredients in your morning beverages to give your brain and body the support they deserve.

However, you’ll want to remember that, like other supplement powders, lion’s mane has a more earthy flavor and texture, which can mess with the taste of whatever's in your cup. 

If you’re not a fan of adding other components (like sugar or milk) to your drink to trump the flavor of the lion’s mane powder, a mushroom tincture or capsule containing Hericium extract might be the way to go.

See related: Lion's Mane vs. Ashwagandha

Lion’s Mane Mushroom Powder vs. Extract: Ease of Use and Flexibility in Daily Routines

When deciding between lion’s mane extract vs. powder, it’s essential to consider your lifestyle and habits to effectively integrate this superfood into your everyday diet. 

In its raw state, the lion’s mane mushroom has a mild, seafood-like flavor that makes it a popular meat replacement in a variety of vegan and vegetarian recipes. However, unless you plan on eating the same meals day in and day out, it’s probably easier to get your daily dose of Hericium elsewhere. This is where powders and capsules come into play. But which is right for you?

  • If you’re looking for something to make your smoothies or morning coffees more nutrient-dense, you may consider adding the mushroom in powder form to these beverages.
  • If you’re not a smoothie lover or you want a no-fuss method for taking lion’s mane while maintaining a busy schedule, the extract found in capsules and tinctures is probably your best bet. 

Whether you’re looking for a mid-afternoon brain boost or something for everyday physical and cognitive support, you can easily add lion’s mane to your routine with either of these methods.

Other Factors to Consider: Price, Organic Certification, and Fillers

While most adaptogenic mushrooms typically have a high price tag with a short shelf life, lion’s mane sets itself apart by offering an array of benefits at a lower cost, especially if you opt for items containing a potent mushroom extract. Depending on the retailer, powders may be a little pricier. 

Aside from the mushroom’s form (powder, extract, sauteed with butter and garlic), it’s also key to consider the quality of what you consume, and always look for mushroom products that are certified organic. This can help you avoid pesticides and other harmful chemicals that may impact the quality of the lion’s mane and the health benefits you receive.

You’ll also want to check out the label of any product containing lion’s mane to ensure it doesn’t contain fillers like sugar and gluten. These fillers don’t enhance the properties and compounds of the mushrooms, and they can actually detract from the quality of the product overall. 

Making the Right Choice: Extract or Powder for Your Health Goals

While there are several ways to consume lion’s mane mushrooms, some options make it easier to get potent, high-quality Hericium into your diet on a daily basis. 

When it comes to choosing between lion's mane powder vs. extract, your deciding factors should be convenience and consistency. Choose whatever mushroom product is easiest for you to integrate into your diet consistently so that you can reap all the benefits that lion’s mane has to offer.

Enjoy Lion’s Mane with Botanic Tonics

From boosting your immune system to helping stabilize your mood, lion’s mane is a multi-faceted, holistic wellness tool that can transform your physical and mental well-being.* If you’re interested in starting to integrate it into your diet, Botanic Tonics is here to help. 

Lion’s mane is one of the key ingredients in our feel free mushroom tonic and capsules, which also boast kava and rhodiola for enhanced focus.* Browse our selection of kava capsules and tonics today. 


  1. Cascadia Mushrooms. Everything You Need to Know About Lion’s Mane Mushrooms. https://cascadiamushrooms.com/blogs/cm/everything-you-need-to-know-about-lions-mane-mushrooms
  2. Forbes Health. Health Benefits of Lion’s Mane. https://www.forbes.com/health/body/health-benefits-of-lions-mane/#:~:text=As%20a%20result%2C%20it%20exhibits,of%20Agricultural%20and%20Food%20Chemistry
  3. International Journal of Molecular Sciences. Therapeutic Potential of Hericium erinaceus for Depressive Disorder. https://www.mdpi.com/1422-0067/21/1/163
  4. Taylor and Francis Online. Hericenones and erinacines: stimulators of nerve growth factor (NGF) biosynthesis in Hericium erinaceus. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/21501201003735556 
  5. National Library of Medicine. Improving effects of the mushroom Yamabushitake (Hericium erinaceus) on mild cognitive impairment: a double-blind placebo-controlled clinical trial. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18844328/ 
  6. Healthline. 9 Health Benefits of Lion’s Mane Mushrooms. https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/lions-mane-mushroom#TOC_TITLE_HDR_5
  7. National Library of Medicine. Immunomodulatory Activities of a Fungal Protein Extracted from Hericium erinaceus through Regulating the Gut Microbiota. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28713364/

About The Author

Jamal Bouie Botanic Tonic

Jamal Bouie

Jamal Bouie is an accomplished professional with a Bachelor’s Degree in Chemistry from Lemoyne-Owen College in Memphis. Currently, he is pursuing his PhD in Biomedicine at Salus University. Jamal has worked in several industries; he began his career in pharmaceutical manufacturing and transitioned to the cannabis industry, where he specialized in analytical testing and manufacturing, playing a vital role in ensuring product safety and compliance. Now, Jamal has turned his attention to the dietary supplement field, combining his scientific acumen with his passion for health and wellness.

Back to blog